- Address
- 1628 Penfield Road, 14625, Rochester
- Hours
- Mon, Tue, Wed, Thu, Sun 11:00 to 22:00Fri and Sat 11:00 to 23:00
- Phone
- +15853852244
Menu read from allstar-pizza.com on 7 November 2026, partly with AI. It may contain mistakes, so check prices with the restaurant. Report a problem with this menu
Menu
195 items · prices in USD
Toppings
- Extra Cheese$1.88
small
The dish you clicked
- Extra Cheese$2.30
medium
The dish you clicked
- Extra Cheese$2.72
large
The dish you clicked
- Extra Cheese$3.77
sheet
The dish you clicked
- Pepperoni$1.88
small
The dish you clicked
- Pepperoni$2.30
medium
The dish you clicked
- Pepperoni$2.72
large
The dish you clicked
- Pepperoni$3.77
sheet
The dish you clicked
- Cup-n-Char Spicy Pepperoni$1.88
small
The dish you clicked
- Cup-n-Char Spicy Pepperoni$2.30
medium
The dish you clicked
- Cup-n-Char Spicy Pepperoni$2.72
large
The dish you clicked
- Cup-n-Char Spicy Pepperoni$3.77
sheet
The dish you clicked
- Mushrooms$1.88
small
The dish you clicked
- Mushrooms$2.30
medium
The dish you clicked
- Mushrooms$2.72
large
The dish you clicked
- Mushrooms$3.77
sheet
The dish you clicked
- Onions$1.88
small
The dish you clicked
- Onions$2.30
medium
The dish you clicked
- Onions$2.72
large
The dish you clicked
- Onions$3.77
sheet
The dish you clicked
- Roasted Red Peppers$1.88
small
The dish you clicked
- Roasted Red Peppers$2.30
medium
The dish you clicked
- Roasted Red Peppers$2.72
large
The dish you clicked
- Roasted Red Peppers$3.77
sheet
The dish you clicked
- Banana Peppers$1.88
small
The dish you clicked
- Banana Peppers$2.30
medium
The dish you clicked
- Banana Peppers$2.72
large
The dish you clicked
- Banana Peppers$3.77
sheet
The dish you clicked
- Green Peppers$1.88
small
The dish you clicked
- Green Peppers$2.30
medium
The dish you clicked
- Green Peppers$2.72
large
The dish you clicked
- Green Peppers$3.77
sheet
The dish you clicked
- Hot Cherry Peppers$1.88
small
The dish you clicked
- Hot Cherry Peppers$2.30
medium
The dish you clicked
- Hot Cherry Peppers$2.72
large
The dish you clicked
- Hot Cherry Peppers$3.77
sheet
The dish you clicked
- Black Olives$1.88
small
The dish you clicked
- Black Olives$2.30
medium
The dish you clicked
- Black Olives$2.72
large
The dish you clicked
- Black Olives$3.77
sheet
The dish you clicked
- Sausage$1.88
small
The dish you clicked
- Sausage$2.30
medium
The dish you clicked
- Sausage$2.72
large
The dish you clicked
- Sausage$3.77
sheet
The dish you clicked
- Meatballs$1.88
small
The dish you clicked
- Meatballs$2.30
medium
The dish you clicked
- Meatballs$2.72
large
The dish you clicked
- Meatballs$3.77
sheet
The dish you clicked
- Anchovies$1.88
small
The dish you clicked
- Anchovies$2.30
medium
The dish you clicked
- Anchovies$2.72
large
The dish you clicked
- Anchovies$3.77
sheet
The dish you clicked
- Ham$1.88
small
The dish you clicked
- Ham$2.30
medium
The dish you clicked
- Ham$2.72
large
The dish you clicked
- Ham$3.77
sheet
The dish you clicked
- Tomatoes$1.88
small
The dish you clicked
- Tomatoes$2.30
medium
The dish you clicked
- Tomatoes$2.72
large
The dish you clicked
- Tomatoes$3.77
sheet
The dish you clicked
- Artichoke Hearts$1.88
small
The dish you clicked
- Artichoke Hearts$2.30
medium
The dish you clicked
- Artichoke Hearts$2.72
large
The dish you clicked
- Artichoke Hearts$3.77
sheet
The dish you clicked
- Bacon$1.88
small
The dish you clicked
- Bacon$2.30
medium
The dish you clicked
- Bacon$2.72
large
The dish you clicked
- Bacon$3.77
sheet
The dish you clicked
- Broccoli$1.88
small
The dish you clicked
- Broccoli$2.30
medium
The dish you clicked
- Broccoli$2.72
large
The dish you clicked
- Broccoli$3.77
sheet
The dish you clicked
- Fresh Spinach$1.88
small
The dish you clicked
- Fresh Spinach$2.30
medium
The dish you clicked
- Fresh Spinach$2.72
large
The dish you clicked
- Fresh Spinach$3.77
sheet
The dish you clicked
- Ricotta Cheese$1.88
small
The dish you clicked
- Ricotta Cheese$2.30
medium
The dish you clicked
- Ricotta Cheese$2.72
large
The dish you clicked
- Ricotta Cheese$3.77
sheet
The dish you clicked
- Cheddar Cheese$1.88
small
The dish you clicked
- Cheddar Cheese$2.30
medium
The dish you clicked
- Cheddar Cheese$2.72
large
The dish you clicked
- Cheddar Cheese$3.77
sheet
The dish you clicked
- Feta cheese$1.88
small
The dish you clicked
- Feta cheese$2.30
medium
The dish you clicked
- Feta cheese$2.72
large
The dish you clicked
- Feta cheese$3.77
sheet
The dish you clicked
Gluten Free
- 10" Gluten Free$1.88
10 in
The dish you clicked
HOT
- Grilled Chicken$12.59
7 in
The dish you clicked
- Grilled Chicken$15.25
12 in
The dish you clicked
- Cheeseburger$12.59
7 in
The dish you clicked
- Cheeseburger$15.25
12 in
The dish you clicked
- Philly Cheese Steak$12.59
7 in
The dish you clicked
- Philly Cheese Steak$15.25
12 in
The dish you clicked
- Roast Beef$12.59
7 in
The dish you clicked
- Roast Beef$15.25
12 in
The dish you clicked
- BBQ Beef$12.59
7 in
The dish you clicked
- BBQ Beef$15.25
12 in
The dish you clicked
- Chicken Finger$12.59
7 in
The dish you clicked
- Chicken Finger$15.25
12 in
The dish you clicked
- Meatball$12.59
7 in
The dish you clicked
- Meatball$15.25
12 in
The dish you clicked
- Chicken Parmesan$12.59
7 in
The dish you clicked
- Chicken Parmesan$15.25
12 in
The dish you clicked
- Eggplant Parmesan$12.59
7 in
The dish you clicked
- Eggplant Parmesan$15.25
12 in
The dish you clicked
- BLT$12.59
7 in
The dish you clicked
- BLT$15.25
12 in
The dish you clicked
Cold
- Italian Assorted$10.49
7 in
The dish you clicked
- Italian Assorted$13.64
12 in
The dish you clicked
- Ham$10.49
7 in
The dish you clicked
- Ham$13.64
12 in
The dish you clicked
- Salami$10.49
7 in
The dish you clicked
- Salami$13.64
12 in
The dish you clicked
- Roast Beef$10.49
7 in
The dish you clicked
- Roast Beef$13.64
12 in
The dish you clicked
- Turkey$10.49
7 in
The dish you clicked
- Turkey$13.64
12 in
The dish you clicked
- Tuna$10.49
7 in
The dish you clicked
- Tuna$13.64
12 in
The dish you clicked
- Veggie$10.49
7 in
The dish you clicked
- Veggie$13.64
12 in
The dish you clicked
- Capicola$10.49
7 in
The dish you clicked
- Capicola$13.64
12 in
The dish you clicked
- Assorted Cheese$10.49
7 in
The dish you clicked
- Assorted Cheese$13.64
12 in
The dish you clicked
Wraps
- Chicken Caesar$10.49
romaine, grilled chicken, parmesan and ceasar dressing. Hot $11.54; Plain, Wheat, Garlic Herb or Sundried Tomato wrap
The dish you clicked
- Turkey Club Wrap$10.49
premium turkey breast, lettuce, tomato, bacon. Hot $11.54; Plain, Wheat, Garlic Herb or Sundried Tomato wrap
The dish you clicked
- Roasted Veggie Wrap$10.49
Garlic Roasted portobello mushrooms, broccoli, artichoke hearts & roasted red peppers. Hot $11.54; Plain, Wheat, Garlic Herb or Sundried Tomato wrap
The dish you clicked
- Buffalo Chicken Wrap$10.49
chicken fingers dipped in buffalo wing sauce with lettuce, tomato, blue cheese. Hot $11.54; Plain, Wheat, Garlic Herb or Sundried Tomato wrap
The dish you clicked
Extras
- Extras Cheese$1.05
7 in
The dish you clicked
- Extras Cheese$1.58
12 in
The dish you clicked
- Extra Meat or Bacon$2.09
7 in
The dish you clicked
- Extra Meat or Bacon$3.14
12 in
The dish you clicked
WINGS
- Wings$8.39
Regular or boneless; includes blue cheese · 5 wings
The dish you clicked
- Wings$15.74
Regular or boneless; includes blue cheese · 10 wings
The dish you clicked
- Wings$30.44
Regular or boneless; includes blue cheese · 20 wings
The dish you clicked
- Wings$41.99
Regular or boneless; includes blue cheese · 30 wings
The dish you clicked
- Wings$68.24
Regular or boneless; includes blue cheese · 50 wings
The dish you clicked
ALL STAR PLATES
- Cheeseburger or Red Hot$15.23
Topped with Ketchup Mustard Onion and Hot Sauce. All plates served with Mac Salad and French Fries
The dish you clicked
- Philly Steak$15.23
Steak with sautéed peppers onions your choice of cheese. All plates served with Mac Salad and French Fries
The dish you clicked
- Chicken Finger$15.23
plain or shaken in your favorite wing sauce. All plates served with Mac Salad and French Fries
The dish you clicked
SALADS
- Tossed Salad$7.34
Romaine, cucumber, tomato, carrots, garbanzo beans, pepperoncini peppers & croutons · Sm.
The dish you clicked
- Tossed Salad$10.49
Romaine, cucumber, tomato, carrots, garbanzo beans, pepperoncini peppers & croutons · Lg.
The dish you clicked
- Julienne Ham, Turkey & Cheese$13.64
The dish you clicked
- Grilled Chicken Salad$13.64
Romaine, grilled chicken, mozzarella, cucumber, tomato, carrots, garbanzo beans, pepperoncini peppers & croutons
The dish you clicked
- Cajun Chicken Salad$13.64
The dish you clicked
- Buffalo Chicken Salad$13.64
The dish you clicked
- Chicken Caesar Salad, w/Bacon$13.64
The dish you clicked
DRESSINGS
- Extra Dressing$0.99
Italian, 1000 Island, Blue Cheese, Ranch, Caesar, Honey Mustard, Vinaigrette & Lite Italian
The dish you clicked
APPETIZERS
- Garlic Bread with Mozzarella & Dipping Sauce$7.34
The dish you clicked
- Pizza Logs$9.44
The dish you clicked
- Mozzarella Sticks (5)$9.44
The dish you clicked
- Mozzarella Sticks (10)$14.69
The dish you clicked
- Fried Mushrooms$8.39
The dish you clicked
- Chicken Fingers$13.64
add fries 2.63
The dish you clicked
- Jalapeño Poppers$7.86
The dish you clicked
- French Fries$4.82
The dish you clicked
- Cheesy Fries$13.64
w/Mozzarella, Cheddar, Bacon and 1 side of any sauce
The dish you clicked
- Onion Rings$6.29
The dish you clicked
- Mac Salad$5.24
The dish you clicked
CALZONES
- Calzone$10.49
Generous portions of Mozzarella & Ricotta stuffed into a garlic seasoned golden brown crust with side of sauce · Regular
The dish you clicked
- Calzone$15.21
Generous portions of Mozzarella & Ricotta stuffed into a garlic seasoned golden brown crust with side of sauce · Large
The dish you clicked
- Extra Sauce$1.04
The dish you clicked
DESSERT
- Fried Dough$6.29
The dish you clicked
- 2 Cookies$2.09
The dish you clicked
Specials
- MEDIUM CHEESE PIZZA PLUS 10 PIECE WINGS OR BONELESS$27.56
Additional toppings extra. One coupon per pizza
The dish you clicked
- LARGE CHEESE PIZZA PLUS 10 PIECE WINGS OR BONELESS$32.56
Additional toppings extra. One coupon per pizza
The dish you clicked
- LARGE CHEESE PIZZA PLUS 20 PIECE WINGS OR BONELESS$44.89
Additional toppings extra. One coupon per pizza
The dish you clicked
- SHEET CHEESE PIZZA Plus 20 Piece Wings or Boneless$53.29
Additional toppings extra. One coupon per pizza
The dish you clicked
- SHEET CHEESE PIZZA Plus 30 Piece Wings or Boneless$65.89
Additional toppings extra. One coupon per pizza
The dish you clicked
- LARGE CHEESE PIZZA$16.79
Additional toppings extra. One coupon per pizza
The dish you clicked
- 2 LARGE CHEESE PIZZAS$33.59
Additional toppings extra. One coupon per pizza
The dish you clicked
4 - 12" Subs
- 4 - 12" Subs$56.69
Turkey, Ham, Italian assorted, Roast Beef, or Tuna. Choice of one cheese · serves 10-12 people
The dish you clicked
- 6 - 12" Subs$78.74
Turkey, Ham, Italian assorted, Roast Beef, or Tuna. Choice of one cheese · serves 14-16 people
The dish you clicked
WRAP TRAYS
- 8 Wraps Cut in 2$66.14
Plain, wheat, garlic herb or tomato basil wraps
The dish you clicked
SALADS
- Tossed Salad$33.59
Romaine, cucumber, tomato, carrots, garbanzo beans, pepperoncini peppers & croutons · serves 10-12 people
The dish you clicked
- Tossed Salad$41.99
Romaine, cucumber, tomato, carrots, garbanzo beans, pepperoncini peppers & croutons · serves 16-18 people
The dish you clicked
- Caesar salad$33.59
Romaine, Caesar dressing, parmesan & croutons · serves 10-12 people
The dish you clicked
- Caesar salad$41.99
Romaine, Caesar dressing, parmesan & croutons · serves 10-12 people, add chicken
The dish you clicked
- Caesar salad$41.99
Romaine, Caesar dressing, parmesan & croutons · serves 16-18 people
The dish you clicked
- Caesar salad$52.49
Romaine, Caesar dressing, parmesan & croutons · serves 16-18 people, add chicken
The dish you clicked
- Grilled Chicken Salad$41.99
Romaine, grilled chicken, mozzarella, cucumber, tomato, carrots, garbanzo beans, pepperoncini peppers & croutons · serves 10-12 people
The dish you clicked
- Grilled Chicken Salad$52.49
Romaine, grilled chicken, mozzarella, cucumber, tomato, carrots, garbanzo beans, pepperoncini peppers & croutons · serves 16-18 people
The dish you clicked
- Greek Salad$41.99
Feta cheese, calamata olives, cucumbers, tomato, & Greek dressing · serves 10-12 people
The dish you clicked
- Greek Salad$52.99
Feta cheese, calamata olives, cucumbers, tomato, & Greek dressing · serves 16-18 people
The dish you clicked
SHEET PIZZAS
- Sheet Pizza$30.44
Toppings $3.77 each: Extra Cheese, Pepperoni, Cup-n-Char Spicy Pepperoni, Mushrooms, Onions, Roasted Red Peppers, Green Peppers, Banana Peppers, Hot Cherry Pepper, Black Olives, Sausage, Meatballs, Anchovies, Ham, Tomatoes, Artichoke Hearts, Bacon, Broccoli, Fresh Spinach, Ricotta Cheese and Chicken (Additional Charge) · sheet
The dish you clicked
BAKED ZITI
- Baked Ziti$41.99
Marinara sauce, mozzarella and ricotta cheese · serves 10-12 people
The dish you clicked
- Baked Ziti$68.24
Marinara sauce, mozzarella and ricotta cheese · serves 20-24 people
The dish you clicked
MEATBALLS W/SAUCE
- Meatballs$39.89
W/Sauce · serves 10-14 people
The dish you clicked
- Meatballs$66.14
W/Sauce · serves 20-24 people
The dish you clicked
EXTRAS
- Bottled Water or Canned Soda$1.58
The dish you clicked
- Bag of Chips$0.79
The dish you clicked
- Cookies$1.04
The dish you clicked