# All Star Pizza

- Address: 1628 Penfield Road, 14625, Rochester
- Phone: +15853852244
- Website: https://www.allstar-pizza.com/
- Open Mo, Tu, We, Th, Su: 11:00–22:00
- Open Fr, Sa: 11:00–23:00
- Page: https://menumap.eu/restaurants/all-star-pizza-rochester
- Menu JSON: https://menumap.eu/api/restaurants/all-star-pizza-rochester/menu

## Menu

All prices in USD. Source: https://www.allstar-pizza.com/menu.html, retrieved 2026-11-07.

### Menu

#### Toppings

- **Extra Cheese** — $1.88 — small
- **Extra Cheese** — $2.30 — medium
- **Extra Cheese** — $2.72 — large
- **Extra Cheese** — $3.77 — sheet
- **Pepperoni** — $1.88 — small
- **Pepperoni** — $2.30 — medium
- **Pepperoni** — $2.72 — large
- **Pepperoni** — $3.77 — sheet
- **Cup-n-Char Spicy Pepperoni** — $1.88 — small
- **Cup-n-Char Spicy Pepperoni** — $2.30 — medium
- **Cup-n-Char Spicy Pepperoni** — $2.72 — large
- **Cup-n-Char Spicy Pepperoni** — $3.77 — sheet
- **Mushrooms** — $1.88 — small
- **Mushrooms** — $2.30 — medium
- **Mushrooms** — $2.72 — large
- **Mushrooms** — $3.77 — sheet
- **Onions** — $1.88 — small
- **Onions** — $2.30 — medium
- **Onions** — $2.72 — large
- **Onions** — $3.77 — sheet
- **Roasted Red Peppers** — $1.88 — small
- **Roasted Red Peppers** — $2.30 — medium
- **Roasted Red Peppers** — $2.72 — large
- **Roasted Red Peppers** — $3.77 — sheet
- **Banana Peppers** — $1.88 — small
- **Banana Peppers** — $2.30 — medium
- **Banana Peppers** — $2.72 — large
- **Banana Peppers** — $3.77 — sheet
- **Green Peppers** — $1.88 — small
- **Green Peppers** — $2.30 — medium
- **Green Peppers** — $2.72 — large
- **Green Peppers** — $3.77 — sheet
- **Hot Cherry Peppers** — $1.88 — small
- **Hot Cherry Peppers** — $2.30 — medium
- **Hot Cherry Peppers** — $2.72 — large
- **Hot Cherry Peppers** — $3.77 — sheet
- **Black Olives** — $1.88 — small
- **Black Olives** — $2.30 — medium
- **Black Olives** — $2.72 — large
- **Black Olives** — $3.77 — sheet
- **Sausage** — $1.88 — small
- **Sausage** — $2.30 — medium
- **Sausage** — $2.72 — large
- **Sausage** — $3.77 — sheet
- **Meatballs** — $1.88 — small
- **Meatballs** — $2.30 — medium
- **Meatballs** — $2.72 — large
- **Meatballs** — $3.77 — sheet
- **Anchovies** — $1.88 — small
- **Anchovies** — $2.30 — medium
- **Anchovies** — $2.72 — large
- **Anchovies** — $3.77 — sheet
- **Ham** — $1.88 — small
- **Ham** — $2.30 — medium
- **Ham** — $2.72 — large
- **Ham** — $3.77 — sheet
- **Tomatoes** — $1.88 — small
- **Tomatoes** — $2.30 — medium
- **Tomatoes** — $2.72 — large
- **Tomatoes** — $3.77 — sheet
- **Artichoke Hearts** — $1.88 — small
- **Artichoke Hearts** — $2.30 — medium
- **Artichoke Hearts** — $2.72 — large
- **Artichoke Hearts** — $3.77 — sheet
- **Bacon** — $1.88 — small
- **Bacon** — $2.30 — medium
- **Bacon** — $2.72 — large
- **Bacon** — $3.77 — sheet
- **Broccoli** — $1.88 — small
- **Broccoli** — $2.30 — medium
- **Broccoli** — $2.72 — large
- **Broccoli** — $3.77 — sheet
- **Fresh Spinach** — $1.88 — small
- **Fresh Spinach** — $2.30 — medium
- **Fresh Spinach** — $2.72 — large
- **Fresh Spinach** — $3.77 — sheet
- **Ricotta Cheese** — $1.88 — small
- **Ricotta Cheese** — $2.30 — medium
- **Ricotta Cheese** — $2.72 — large
- **Ricotta Cheese** — $3.77 — sheet
- **Cheddar Cheese** — $1.88 — small
- **Cheddar Cheese** — $2.30 — medium
- **Cheddar Cheese** — $2.72 — large
- **Cheddar Cheese** — $3.77 — sheet
- **Feta cheese** — $1.88 — small
- **Feta cheese** — $2.30 — medium
- **Feta cheese** — $2.72 — large
- **Feta cheese** — $3.77 — sheet

#### Gluten Free

- **10" Gluten Free** — $1.88 — 10 in

#### HOT

- **Grilled Chicken** — $12.59 — 7 in
- **Grilled Chicken** — $15.25 — 12 in
- **Cheeseburger** — $12.59 — 7 in
- **Cheeseburger** — $15.25 — 12 in
- **Philly Cheese Steak** — $12.59 — 7 in
- **Philly Cheese Steak** — $15.25 — 12 in
- **Roast Beef** — $12.59 — 7 in
- **Roast Beef** — $15.25 — 12 in
- **BBQ Beef** — $12.59 — 7 in
- **BBQ Beef** — $15.25 — 12 in
- **Chicken Finger** — $12.59 — 7 in
- **Chicken Finger** — $15.25 — 12 in
- **Meatball** — $12.59 — 7 in
- **Meatball** — $15.25 — 12 in
- **Chicken Parmesan** — $12.59 — 7 in
- **Chicken Parmesan** — $15.25 — 12 in
- **Eggplant Parmesan** — $12.59 — 7 in
- **Eggplant Parmesan** — $15.25 — 12 in
- **BLT** — $12.59 — 7 in
- **BLT** — $15.25 — 12 in

#### Cold

- **Italian Assorted** — $10.49 — 7 in
- **Italian Assorted** — $13.64 — 12 in
- **Ham** — $10.49 — 7 in
- **Ham** — $13.64 — 12 in
- **Salami** — $10.49 — 7 in
- **Salami** — $13.64 — 12 in
- **Roast Beef** — $10.49 — 7 in
- **Roast Beef** — $13.64 — 12 in
- **Turkey** — $10.49 — 7 in
- **Turkey** — $13.64 — 12 in
- **Tuna** — $10.49 — 7 in
- **Tuna** — $13.64 — 12 in
- **Veggie** — $10.49 — 7 in
- **Veggie** — $13.64 — 12 in
- **Capicola** — $10.49 — 7 in
- **Capicola** — $13.64 — 12 in
- **Assorted Cheese** — $10.49 — 7 in
- **Assorted Cheese** — $13.64 — 12 in

#### Wraps

- **Chicken Caesar** — $10.49 — romaine, grilled chicken, parmesan and ceasar dressing. Hot $11.54; Plain, Wheat, Garlic Herb or Sundried Tomato wrap
- **Turkey Club Wrap** — $10.49 — premium turkey breast, lettuce, tomato, bacon. Hot $11.54; Plain, Wheat, Garlic Herb or Sundried Tomato wrap
- **Roasted Veggie Wrap** — $10.49 — Garlic Roasted portobello mushrooms, broccoli, artichoke hearts & roasted red peppers. Hot $11.54; Plain, Wheat, Garlic Herb or Sundried Tomato wrap
- **Buffalo Chicken Wrap** — $10.49 — chicken fingers dipped in buffalo wing sauce with lettuce, tomato, blue cheese. Hot $11.54; Plain, Wheat, Garlic Herb or Sundried Tomato wrap

#### Extras

- **Extras Cheese** — $1.05 — 7 in
- **Extras Cheese** — $1.58 — 12 in
- **Extra Meat or Bacon** — $2.09 — 7 in
- **Extra Meat or Bacon** — $3.14 — 12 in

#### WINGS

- **Wings** — $8.39 — Regular or boneless; includes blue cheese · 5 wings
- **Wings** — $15.74 — Regular or boneless; includes blue cheese · 10 wings
- **Wings** — $30.44 — Regular or boneless; includes blue cheese · 20 wings
- **Wings** — $41.99 — Regular or boneless; includes blue cheese · 30 wings
- **Wings** — $68.24 — Regular or boneless; includes blue cheese · 50 wings

#### ALL STAR PLATES

- **Cheeseburger or Red Hot** — $15.23 — Topped with Ketchup Mustard Onion and Hot Sauce. All plates served with Mac Salad and French Fries
- **Philly Steak** — $15.23 — Steak with sautéed peppers onions your choice of cheese. All plates served with Mac Salad and French Fries
- **Chicken Finger** — $15.23 — plain or shaken in your favorite wing sauce. All plates served with Mac Salad and French Fries

#### SALADS

- **Tossed Salad** — $7.34 — Romaine, cucumber, tomato, carrots, garbanzo beans, pepperoncini peppers & croutons · Sm.
- **Tossed Salad** — $10.49 — Romaine, cucumber, tomato, carrots, garbanzo beans, pepperoncini peppers & croutons · Lg.
- **Julienne Ham, Turkey & Cheese** — $13.64
- **Grilled Chicken Salad** — $13.64 — Romaine, grilled chicken, mozzarella, cucumber, tomato, carrots, garbanzo beans, pepperoncini peppers & croutons
- **Cajun Chicken Salad** — $13.64
- **Buffalo Chicken Salad** — $13.64
- **Chicken Caesar Salad, w/Bacon** — $13.64

#### DRESSINGS

- **Extra Dressing** — $0.99 — Italian, 1000 Island, Blue Cheese, Ranch, Caesar, Honey Mustard, Vinaigrette & Lite Italian

#### APPETIZERS

- **Garlic Bread with Mozzarella & Dipping Sauce** — $7.34
- **Pizza Logs** — $9.44
- **Mozzarella Sticks (5)** — $9.44
- **Mozzarella Sticks (10)** — $14.69
- **Fried Mushrooms** — $8.39
- **Chicken Fingers** — $13.64 — add fries 2.63
- **Jalapeño Poppers** — $7.86
- **French Fries** — $4.82
- **Cheesy Fries** — $13.64 — w/Mozzarella, Cheddar, Bacon and 1 side of any sauce
- **Onion Rings** — $6.29
- **Mac Salad** — $5.24

#### CALZONES

- **Calzone** — $10.49 — Generous portions of Mozzarella & Ricotta stuffed into a garlic seasoned golden brown crust with side of sauce · Regular
- **Calzone** — $15.21 — Generous portions of Mozzarella & Ricotta stuffed into a garlic seasoned golden brown crust with side of sauce · Large
- **Extra Sauce** — $1.04

#### DESSERT

- **Fried Dough** — $6.29
- **2 Cookies** — $2.09

#### Specials

- **MEDIUM CHEESE PIZZA PLUS 10 PIECE WINGS OR BONELESS** — $27.56 — Additional toppings extra. One coupon per pizza
- **LARGE CHEESE PIZZA PLUS 10 PIECE WINGS OR BONELESS** — $32.56 — Additional toppings extra. One coupon per pizza
- **LARGE CHEESE PIZZA PLUS 20 PIECE WINGS OR BONELESS** — $44.89 — Additional toppings extra. One coupon per pizza
- **SHEET CHEESE PIZZA Plus 20 Piece Wings or Boneless** — $53.29 — Additional toppings extra. One coupon per pizza
- **SHEET CHEESE PIZZA Plus 30 Piece Wings or Boneless** — $65.89 — Additional toppings extra. One coupon per pizza
- **LARGE CHEESE PIZZA** — $16.79 — Additional toppings extra. One coupon per pizza
- **2 LARGE CHEESE PIZZAS** — $33.59 — Additional toppings extra. One coupon per pizza

#### 4 - 12" Subs

- **4 - 12" Subs** — $56.69 — Turkey, Ham, Italian assorted, Roast Beef, or Tuna. Choice of one cheese · serves 10-12 people
- **6 - 12" Subs** — $78.74 — Turkey, Ham, Italian assorted, Roast Beef, or Tuna. Choice of one cheese · serves 14-16 people

#### WRAP TRAYS

- **8 Wraps Cut in 2** — $66.14 — Plain, wheat, garlic herb or tomato basil wraps

#### SALADS

- **Tossed Salad** — $33.59 — Romaine, cucumber, tomato, carrots, garbanzo beans, pepperoncini peppers & croutons · serves 10-12 people
- **Tossed Salad** — $41.99 — Romaine, cucumber, tomato, carrots, garbanzo beans, pepperoncini peppers & croutons · serves 16-18 people
- **Caesar salad** — $33.59 — Romaine, Caesar dressing, parmesan & croutons · serves 10-12 people
- **Caesar salad** — $41.99 — Romaine, Caesar dressing, parmesan & croutons · serves 10-12 people, add chicken
- **Caesar salad** — $41.99 — Romaine, Caesar dressing, parmesan & croutons · serves 16-18 people
- **Caesar salad** — $52.49 — Romaine, Caesar dressing, parmesan & croutons · serves 16-18 people, add chicken
- **Grilled Chicken Salad** — $41.99 — Romaine, grilled chicken, mozzarella, cucumber, tomato, carrots, garbanzo beans, pepperoncini peppers & croutons · serves 10-12 people
- **Grilled Chicken Salad** — $52.49 — Romaine, grilled chicken, mozzarella, cucumber, tomato, carrots, garbanzo beans, pepperoncini peppers & croutons · serves 16-18 people
- **Greek Salad** — $41.99 — Feta cheese, calamata olives, cucumbers, tomato, & Greek dressing · serves 10-12 people
- **Greek Salad** — $52.99 — Feta cheese, calamata olives, cucumbers, tomato, & Greek dressing · serves 16-18 people

#### SHEET PIZZAS

- **Sheet Pizza** — $30.44 — Toppings $3.77 each: Extra Cheese, Pepperoni, Cup-n-Char Spicy Pepperoni, Mushrooms, Onions, Roasted Red Peppers, Green Peppers, Banana Peppers, Hot Cherry Pepper, Black Olives, Sausage, Meatballs, Anchovies, Ham, Tomatoes, Artichoke Hearts, Bacon, Broccoli, Fresh Spinach, Ricotta Cheese and Chicken (Additional Charge) · sheet

#### BAKED ZITI

- **Baked Ziti** — $41.99 — Marinara sauce, mozzarella and ricotta cheese · serves 10-12 people
- **Baked Ziti** — $68.24 — Marinara sauce, mozzarella and ricotta cheese · serves 20-24 people

#### MEATBALLS W/SAUCE

- **Meatballs** — $39.89 — W/Sauce · serves 10-14 people
- **Meatballs** — $66.14 — W/Sauce · serves 20-24 people

#### EXTRAS

- **Bottled Water or Canned Soda** — $1.58
- **Bag of Chips** — $0.79
- **Cookies** — $1.04
